It's about our community and our spirituality!

A Glimpse Into The Black Abyss America Likes To See

Here’s the problem: despite the success of famous black actors like Denzel Washington and Samuel L. Jackson and the like, mainstream audiences from the racially generic dominant community don’t particularly care for black movies that paint black characters as overwhelmingly heroic or positive.  Mainstream America likes its black films a little more gritty with black men being the scum of the earth.  I just read a review of the film that gave the stark example that while a movie like The Great Debaters which cost fifteen million dollars in 2007 and grossed a decent thirty three million dollars or so since its release, a movie like The Color Purple, which also cost fifteen million dollars in 1985, grossed almost one hundred million dollars by 1987.

In the Color Purple, Danny Glover’s character Mister was a man you really didn’t mind hating.  Mister treated the heroine, his wife Celie Harris played by Whoopi Goldberg, like a slave.  He abused her.  Celie was also abused and sexually raped by her stepfather.  By the time she is fourteen, she has already had two children by her stepfather who takes them away from her and forces her to marry the local widower named Albert Johnson whom she comes to refer to as Mister.  Mister beats her often and intimidates her into complete submission.  These were two black men America really learned to enjoy hating and stood in line at the box office to do so.

Conversely, Denzel Washington’s character Melvin B. Tolson in The Great Debaters is cerebral.  He is an instructor at historically black Wiley College working to place his debating team on equal footing with white students from ivory league schools.  Mr. Tolson struggles to keep his team together in the American South during the early part of the century when Jim Crow laws were an institutionalized part of the social fabric.  The movie depicts several instances where Mr. Tolson encounters lynch mobs and must exhibit smarts and courage to keep his students safe.  The Wiley team eventually succeeds and wins the ultimate, a debate with the white students from none other than Harvard University.  That was a black man America could admire, but who wanted to pay to see that?

So given this oversimplified context, what can we expect for a movie like Precious, a screen adaptation of the book Push from author Sapphire, formerly Ramona Lofton.  Precious is the story of a young and grossly overweight African American girl who is functionally illiterate and full of self loathing.  At just sixteen years old, Claireece Precious Jones has already given birth to two children fathered by her father.  She suffers constant physical and psychological abuse from her mother Mary, played by Mo’Nique.  From what I understand, in one extremely violent scene, Mary drops her three day old grandson, Precious’ baby, in order to try and bitch slap Precious into the middle of next week.  If mainstream America enjoyed hating Mister, they will go utterly ape shit over the hateful sentiment that will be aimed at the family of this girl.

When the movie made its test debut at the Sundance festival, rumor is that it received three standing ovations.  Test proved that America was ready to see another film full of black family dysfunction, cruelty of a mental, physical, and sexual nature.  Since then, the marketing team for the studio that obtained the rights for the film has pulled out all the stops.  Indeed, I must confess that when I heard the first reviews of the movie while listening to National Public Radio, I was intrigued.  There aren’t that many movies that feature a predominantly black cast aimed squarely at middle America.  This was a movie that I thought might be worth supporting.

But like most movies and documentaries about life in black America, the black community is not the prime target for this film.  The black community isn’t a secondary target.  The black community doesn’t even register in the marketing plan.  This film and its story is produced for the sole benefit of the racially generic mainstream America that continues to define what it means to be black in America.

If mainstream America wanted to see black films like The Great Debaters, Antoine Fisher, a Soldier Story, Boomerang, Bamboozled, and the like, we would have them.  These black films not only told a story, but helped to offer a different perspective, helped to build a more rounded idea of life in the black community.  But this isn’t where the money is to be made.  Overwhelmingly, the most profitable perspective of black life, the one that America loves to see most, is the one without much redemption for the main characters.

Depictions of the black community in its lowest form will always get the dominant community’s collective attention.  It’s why so many people tune into the news or watch the show Cops or whatever suffices as a police chase that ends with black people going to jail or being brutally assaulted by law enforcers.  America likes that kind of stuff.  And America loves the voyeurism associated with peeking into the blackest abyss of life in the black community.  There is little doubt that Precious will be a box office phenomenon.  This is the type of story mainstream America wants to use as its foundation for its limited understanding of black people.

Monday, December 14, 2009 - Posted by | African Americans, Black Community, Black Culture, Black People, Life, Racism, Thoughts


  1. I would have to agree with your assessment. I have noticed like you, that smart film about or just starring black people do so poorly in the box office. Which of course brings down the quality of films starring black actors and actresses.

    You also see films doing very well which portrays the black actors and actresses as the selfless savior, the happy black mammy, funny black sidekick or pathetic bossy no life having but chock full of wisdom and advice girlfriend. We see all these characters constantly in movies such as The Green Mile, any Madea movie, Norbit, the Klumps, Bringing Down the House, Bagger Vance, Driving Miss Daisy, What dreams may come and oh so many more.

    There are far more movies showing black people in these stupid movies than in anything with substance. And I really don’t want to hear anything about Will Smith movies. That is a whole post in itself.

    But, again this is a great post and it also goes to show that some of us are complicit in this junk. Just look how blacks are turning out to see Disney’s garbage. But on the flip side, black people can turn out to a movie in force and it will still not be a success in the box office.

    What to do? Thanks.

    Comment by theblacksentinel | Tuesday, December 15, 2009 | Reply

  2. BP, this is by far the best and most honest critique of this movie. I saw it, knew I was going to be disappointed before I did but I went along for the ride. I had to control myself from regurgitating. I am so sick and tired if the trash put out by Black people then tout it as “genius.” Truth of the matter is we have become the tool of our own distruction. We have become master of mediocrity, and the consumers thereof.


    Comment by Amenta | Wednesday, December 16, 2009 | Reply

  3. A few movies I liked were The Great Debaters, The Secret Life of Bees, and Rose (wood/ville?). Anymore I dont bother to watch any movie in the theater, I ait for it to come out on video so I can read the description of the movie first to find out if its actually quality and worth watching.

    Comment by Mike Lovell | Friday, December 18, 2009 | Reply

  4. please do not be disheartened, even in Mandela’s paradise called south africa we suffer the same fate. although our movie industry is nowhere as big as the US market, the stereotypes play themselves out in tv ads (a pet hate for me) music videos, etc.. i do think though that we as a people must start focussing on how ‘we do unto ourselves’….i have since started a blog as my contribution to the dialogue on how images promoted commercially are the ones that re-enforce the white lies ( )

    please stay mad, it is the only way we can get our voices heard – for silence (whether out of exasperation or sheer anger) might be misconstrued as consent.

    namaste !

    Comment by za | Saturday, December 19, 2009 | Reply

  5. I think that white (and all other) film audiences just like to see movies about people of all races living under horrible circumstances.

    Comment by Brian | Sunday, December 27, 2009 | Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: