It's about our community and our spirituality!

South Africa Is Ready To Defend Caster Semenya


Caster Semenya is headed back to school.  The last bit of news I heard about her was that the pending result of her sex test continues to dominate the track world’s headlines.  But in an astonishing display of change the South African Government is ready to use its political influence to support their maligned daughter if the findings from the International Association of Athletics Foundation, the IAAF, go against her.  To counter the attack against Ms. Semenya, Leonard Chuene, president of Athletics South Africa, is ready to respond with a two pronged response using sports and politics.  Mr. Chuene went on record saying that Ms. Semenya comes from a family of meager means and her status as something other than female is being taken for granted because she does not have the resources to defend herself.  Mr. Chuene says that Ms. Semenya has become a ward of the South Africa and her case has been given full consideration by the government, suggesting that she has the political and financial backing for a fight

ASIAD2006-DOHA-ATHLETICS-IND-SEXPeople have learned a little something from the way the IAAF ran rough shod over Santhi Soundarajan.  Ms. Soundarajan was an Indian runner who was stripped of her silver medal she won at the 2006 Asian Games after she failed a gender verification test.  It was Ms. Soundarajan’s opinion that since she had come from a small village and had no one to help her in her fight against the IAAF.  Ms. Soundarajan was diagnosed with Androgen Insensitivity Syndrome (AIS) diagnosed and was unqualified to compete with woman’s running ever since, her career ruined.  Mr. Chuene is determined that Ms. Semenya doesn’t end up suffering the same fate.

What I find most amazing about this turn of events is the fact that this support comes from the South African government.  This is the same government that just two decades ago was neck deep in government sanctioned apartheid, state sanctioned racial discrimination against blacks.  It took the country less than twenty years to change its mode of operation of treating black people as something to be unworthy of equal status and to morph that into a country that would actually support a black woman accused of being something other than a woman.  South Africa isn’t passively waiting for some jury elsewhere to give their verdict indicating whether or not Ms. Semenya is one hundred percent female before it decides to give their support.  South Africa stands ready now to defend Ms. Semenya with everything it’s got.

In contrast, many people in the black community are waiting for some confirmation of gender from the IAAF’s doctors and other specialists that Ms. Semenya is indeed what she claims to be before they would embrace this sister.  In a lot of people’s eyes, she’s too manly or too muscle bound to be worth supporting.  It’s only after somebody like the various doctors of the IAAF give their seal of approval will these people then change their position and support people “like this”, meaning those who may possess an abnormality such as AIS.

But while doing a little research on this topic, one thing that became apparent was the fact that Ms. Semenya and Ms. Soundarajan were both from locales where poverty is the norm.  In fact, according to her coach, Ms. Soundarajan was brought up in a rural India environment so impoverished that she only started eating proper meals in 2004, at the age of twenty three.  After years of her body adapting to doing without adequate food, a healthy meal probably gave her more energy than she ever needed, giving her much more stamina than her body ever thought possible.  Indeed, it may have been the lack of adequate nutrition during her crucial growth years that led to Ms. Soundarajan’s body having underdeveloped sex organs.  And now people think that the years of dealing with hunger and possibly starvation gives people like her and Ms. Semenya an unfair advantage.

This is just a theory.  There is no scientific evidence to support this argument.  I wouldn’t really know how to prove anything scientifically to save my life.  But by the same token, it has yet to be proven that Ms. Semenya has AIS or any other gender abnormality and yet people feel entitled to disqualify her and hold her up to suspicion with little facts other than her appearance and the sound of her voice.  To compound that unresolved question, it has yet to be adequately proven that a condition of AIS gives anyone some unfair performance advantage.  This is why the South African government wants to come to her aid to make sure that any condemnation of Ms. Semenya is truly proven beyond any shadow of doubt.  Hunches and suspicions and arbitrary gender testing does not qualify.

The country that is best known for its shameful treatment of black people is coming to the aid and supporting this product of the black community.  This is the same country with a history that back in the day would never allow a black person to run on any track with a white person.  They understand the stakes.  A contest between the IAAF and Ms. Semenya is no contest at all.  The IAAF has a history of using the suspicion of AIS as a reason to destroy reputations of people who have no means to question anything about the results.

This young lady needed someone to believe in her if she is going to come through this with her dignity and her reputation intact.  I give my complements to the South African people for their willingness as a collective to step to the plate and combat this prejudice against their daughter.  It is simply too bad that more people don’t have the courage to stand by her and to support her and to believe that she has earned every right to be on the field running in competition with other women.

Tuesday, September 8, 2009 - Posted by | African Americans, Black Community, Black Culture, Black People, Caster Semenya, Life, Racism, Thoughts


  1. I was really upset to see the way she was treated. That is so unfair and if that was suppose to be anyone from the so called European countries, they would have tried to keep her away from the media and not let anyone interview her without her coach being around. That girl was put under so much stress and given that she has to compete was never taken into account but instead, there were some journalists who used the opportunity to ask her stupid questions and I felt she was on her own which to me was just wrong. Nevertheless with all that was going around her, she still managed to keep her cool and not let any of that bothered her. WELL DONE MY DARLING for showing strength and courage.Anyone else would have broken down and shy away. To me, I have more respect for her than most of the officials who just could not protect her from those praying paps.

    Comment by Ace | Wednesday, September 9, 2009 | Reply

  2. I hope getting a make over made her feel good.

    Comment by Amy | Wednesday, September 9, 2009 | Reply

  3. so naturally they found that she is both male and female…go figure. Hopefully during the lead up and the next summer olympics South Africa just starts kicking the crap out of everyone in all the events, and then to show their disapproval, ask the medal people to mail them later because they wont show up at the ceremonies!

    Comment by Mike Lovell | Friday, September 11, 2009 | Reply

  4. Thanks for the feedback Mike Lovell,

    Next year they should come out with a more comprehensive standard for testing. All the women should be tested and anyone who fails their gender testing should have their name splayed out all over every media source.


    Comment by brotherpeacemaker | Friday, September 11, 2009 | Reply

  5. Sorry, she is NOT both male and female. She is a female with male characteristics. There is a difference. She does NOT have a penis but she seems to have undescended testes which are not mature.

    She does have the feminine outer female genitalia but not the inner ones such as ovaries. So that makes her more female than male. Since her testosterone is still within normal female range that clearly means she is more female and thus doesn’t have some advantage.

    I don’t think that this genetic testing is appropriate. I will agree with the gender tests and think that BrotherP has a point. She has been maligned by this and they should do the same to any other female OR male that they find has an abnormality.

    Put them on display and embarrass, harass and accuse until that person just drops out of site. Too bad that this is what we do to people.


    Comment by theblacksentinel | Friday, September 11, 2009 | Reply

  6. One of the worse things to me appears to be the way that Caster and her family found out about her condition. They assumed “girl” all her life and though she remains female, she now she has some issues to contend with that were never issues before and all while her body is still maturing to final growth (think about your own sexual misgivings at age 13 or so multiplied by a power of ten).
    Personally though I feel this is more about discrimination against the poor and intersexuals than about race. But the whole debacle concerning the Williams sisters and The Great White Hope of White Women Tennis Players, Ms. Melanie Oudin from Georgia-that IS about race and the way blacks have begun to encroach on white country club sports like golf and tennis.

    Comment by Carlton | Saturday, September 12, 2009 | Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: